Showing posts with label public policy forum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label public policy forum. Show all posts

Monday, May 25, 2009

Conference Board of Canada Controversy & American Based Copyright Lobbying - the Substantive Issues

Those who wish to pay $1,595 to attend a Conference Board of Canada conference this Friday May 29, 2009 that is reportedly being funded in the amount of $15,000 by Ontario taxpayers, according to ITBusiness, at which a controversial Conference Board of Canada report will be presented can find out more information about the Conference here. Prof. Geist has described this as a "deceptive, plagiarized rerport" and there's a front page article about all this in today's Ottawa Citizen.

While there are some good speakers on the list of this Conference Board Conference, the program and speaker list are seriously imbalanced in my view. It is regrettable that prestigious institutions such as the Public Policy Forum last year and the Conference Board of Canada this year allow themselves to be used in this way by lobbyists.

Those wishing to read the 2008 American IIPA lobbyist's report from which the Conference Board report has allegedly taken portions of its content can read it for free here.

These reports on Canada are prepared with the considerable input of a well known Washington lawyer named Steve Metalitz.

As it happens, I debated this very report with Mr. Metalitz at the 2008 Fordham conference, where I presented a paper entitled WHY CANADIAN COPYRIGHT LAW IS ALREADY STRONGER AND BETTER THAN THAT OF THE USA - AND WHY THE USA SHOULD LOOK IN THE MIRROR RATHER THAN AT ITS “SPECIAL 301" WATCH LIST.

This paper shows 15 ways in which Canadian copyright law is already stronger and better than American copyright law. None of those points have been refuted. These include a number of provisions that generate substantial amounts of money that benefit - in some cases mostly and significantly benefit - American interests, and for which the USA has no equivalent counterpart provisions. Here's a simplified "baker's dozen" list of examples from my paper:
  1. Payment by broadcasters for "ephemeral rights"
  2. Payment for public performance by small business establishments
  3. Neigbouring rights for sound recording producers and performers
  4. Theatrical exhibition rights for composers and authors
  5. Blank media levies
  6. Far higher reprography payments per capita - particularly in educational sector
  7. Moral rights
  8. No compulsory mechanical license
  9. About 36 copyright collectives (about six or seven times more than USA)
  10. Largest copyright tribunal infrastructure of any country that I know of
  11. No parody right
  12. No time shifting exemption
  13. Crown copyright, which results in private sector monetization.
So - in the current debate, which ironically involves allegations of plagiarism in the context of copyright lobbying - let us not lose sight of the basic underlying issues:
  1. In many ways which involve a lot of money flowing out of Canada to US interests, our Canadian copyright laws are already stronger and better than American laws.
  2. The USA remains the world's longest and most flagrant outstanding adjudicated international copyright scofflaw, as determined by the WTO now 9 years ago.
HK

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Bordering on Fiction

It’s interesting that the new U.S. Homeland Security Secretary, Janet Napolitano, believes that terrorists have routinely entered the United Sates through Canada — including the perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks. If such ill-informed, clearly harmful and inaccurate myths are really believed by high American officials, the resulting US Government demands could seriously impair ease of travel and increase shipping costs and inconvenience for Canadian businesses. Such measures could render cross border trade uncompetitive in some cases. So much for free trade. Could this all possibly be a disingenuous excuse for more protectionism? Trade lawyers would be shocked, shocked if such were the case.

Speaking of never letting a crisis (whether real or concocted) go to waste, it was apparent at last week's Fordham conference held at Cambridge, England that American USTR and Department of Commerce (USPTO) officials are similarly ill informed about piracy, counterfeiting and Canadian border and IP issues in general. This has clearly driven the USA ACTA and “Special 301" agendas.

The American officials actually do seem to believe that Canada is a major gateway for transhipping fake goods to the USA and that fake goods are actually made here in Canada in quantity. But where is the evidence for this? It seems that a key source of these allegations about Canada is that of Canadian based lobbyists for American content owner interests.

Don't be surprised if, based upon such “evidence”, Canada is promoted to the worst of the worst list on this year's “Special 301" report, expected any day now. Clearly, the Canadian lobbyists who act for their American bosses and profess to be interested in the cause of Canadian artists are getting a lot of traction. Even US Vice President Joe Biden now has Canada in his sights, along with China:
Biden blasted China, saying its intellectual property laws remain "largely ineffective" and will end up "strangling their own creative juices," and compared it to what he described as India's more effective anti-piracy regime. He singled out Canada, a close U.S. ally, as needing stronger laws; it never signed the treaty that led to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and a proposal to adopt anti-circumvention restrictions was never adopted.
I'd like to think that our Canadian government is doing its best to inform the US Government of facts, rather than passively letting special interest lobbyists feed unfettered fiction into the American policy making machine.

The fact is that Canada has long had in place very effective border enforcement mechanisms that operate under the jurisdiction of the courts, as they should. “Ex officio” measures that would empower Canadian border officials to decide matters on their own that should be left to the judicial process are not needed or even desirable in Canada. As I've pointed out before, Justice Roger Hughes, who has extraordinary experience as both a Canadian IP litigator and now as a Federal Court Judge, provided an important comment last year at Fordham that takes the wind out of the sails of those who advocate "ex officio" actions at Canadian borders:
Justice Roger Hughes of the Canadian Federal Court commented from the audience in response to Steve Metalitz’s suggestion that Canada lacks adequate and effective border measures and should provide “ex officio” seizures (i.e. seizures that bypass the Courts and let customs officials seize allegedly pirated or counterfeit goods). According to Mr. Metalitz, the current system doesn’t work. Justice Hughes pointed out that this was simply wrong and that judicial orders for seizures were readily available when appropriate – and that those seeking such a change should “stop whining” and just “roll up their sleeves” in order to use the current system. He indicated that he had signed three such orders at the request of Microsoft just in the last week.
The fact is that counterfeit and pirated products are not freely and openly available on the main streets of major Canadian cities, as they are in New York City, for example. Why blame Canada for a problem that the USA cannot or will not address even in mid-town Manhattan?

As to piracy and counterfeiting in general, the late Sir Hugh Laddie told The Times in a story on June 3, 2008 a few months before his death last year:
"Of course there is counterfeiting in China, but the same goes on in the US and Europe. Pro rata, the biggest source of pirated computer software in the world in the US.”
It’s time for facts about piracy, counterfeiting and what happens at borders. We need to move beyond lobbyists’ fabrications bordering on fiction.

HK

PS:

BTW, if anyone wishes to pay $1,595 for a one day program (which includes lunch) to attend what promises to be an enthusiastic presentation of American government and American content owners’ points of view voiced directly and through Canadian lobbyists on some of the above topics, the Conference Board of Canada is hosting just such an event on May 29, 2009 in Toronto. Here’s the program.

Friday, April 25, 2008

Uninvited to the Public Policy Forum Symposium

I have now been uninvited to the Public Policy Forum (“PPF”) IP program entitled INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY REFORM: INNOVATION AND THE ECONOMY on April 28, 2008, which will now proceed without me on the program.

It seems that strong pressure was brought to bear on PPF to have me removed from the program and that PPF capitulated.

The presentation that I would have made would have been based upon the presentation I gave at the 16h Annual Fordham conference in NYC on March 28, 2008 entitled:

WHY CANADIAN COPYRIGHT LAW IS ALREADY STRONGER AND BETTER THAN THAT OF THE USA - AND WHY THE USA SHOULD LOOK IN THE MIRROR RATHER THAN AT ITS “SPECIAL 301" WATCH LIST

Here is that paper, which documents several weaknesses in American copyright law and some 15 areas in which Canadian copyright law is already stronger and better than American law, many of which result in very substantial outflows of money to the USA. The paper also points out hypocrisy and inconsistencies in American positions on IP, including with respect to the US “301" mechanism. I was also asked to address a some points in patent and trade-marks law.

However, it seems that some interests do not want to hear about these points at this conference. I have done a lot of research in this area, and nobody has suggested that anything in the Fordham paper was inaccurate in any respect. In fact, it was well received.

I had looked forward to debating these points with Glen Bloom in particular on the panel in which I had been included, and others, who will also assuredly take a different point of view. Mr. Bloom is a registered lobbyist for Time Canada Ltd., Warner Bros. Entertainment Canada Inc., AOL Canada Inc., and The Canadian Motion Picture Distributors Association.

Since this is a program that could influence the development of Canadian law, I had hoped to provide at least some additional counterbalance to the overwhelming presence of spokespersons for multinational (largely American) based interests who will also include U.S. Ambassador David Wilkins, Michael Shapiro of the USPTO (who asked me two weeks ago for a digital copy of my Fordham paper) , and Perrin Beatty of the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, which takes a very USTR friendly view of IP matters.

I would have expected more from the PPF, based upon their own language:

The Public Policy Forum's mission is to strive for excellence in government - to serve as a neutral, independent forum for open dialogue on public policy, and to encourage reform in public sector management. Four key factors have distinguished the PPF as a unique organization on the Canadian landscape.


First, the Forum stands resolutely in its belief that high quality government is critical to Canada's quality of life as well as to our prospects as a competitive nation in the global economy. High quality government requires a fundamental commitment to excellence in public policy development and public sector management - a commitment not only by those who govern, but also by business, labour, the academic community, the media, and the voluntary sector.


Second, the PPF has established itself as a neutral, trusted facilitator. It provides a meeting place where diverse and often opposing opinions and interests can be aired openly and debated, and opportunities can be sought for mutual understanding and collaboration.


Third, unlike other public policy organizations, the PPF does not sit in judgment of what government does, but looks at how public policy is developed and how the public service is managed. This approach has enabled it to bring together Canadians from all sectors of society and political viewpoints.


Finally, the PPF lives by its mandate of seeking membership that represents all sectors in Canada.
(Emphasis added)

More in sadness than in anger, I must say that I am disappointed in the PPF for capitulating to pressure in this instance. I am afraid that this episode may prove to be very symbolic of the overwhelming efforts and forces that will be brought to bear on the Canadian Government on the IP front in the future.

Everyone is entitled to their viewpoint. So, it is particularly sad, regrettable and ultimately ironic that an institution such as the Public Policy Forum would permit such blunt interference in the marketplace of ideas in Canada.

HK

PS: Michael Geist and the incredibly widely read BoingBoing are onto this.

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Public Policy Forum Program April 28, 2008

The prestigious Public Policy Forum is putting on a very provocative and informative program on April 28, 2008 on INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY REFORM: INNOVATION AND THE ECONOMY.

Speakers will include Ambassador Wilkins, Perrin Beatty, James Rajotte, Michael Geist, Glen Bloom, Richard Gold, myself and many others.

Here's the program.

It covers much more than copyright, but will likely be very interesting on that topic alone.

I expect that there will be a lot of talk of Canada/USA relations and comparisons.

It's in Ottawa at the Chateau Laurier. It's a good value at $350. Here's where to register.

HK