Showing posts with label parallel import. Show all posts
Showing posts with label parallel import. Show all posts

Saturday, June 09, 2018

Unsettling Comments from the Ontario Courts re the Settled Law of Trademarks and Parallel Importation




The Ontario courts have made some unsettling comments suggesting that the Canadian trademarks law is “unsettled” on the issue of parallel imports or grey marketing. Ironically, like the leading Canadian case on parallel imports discussed below, this also appears to be a case about chocolate bars. The comments were made in the context of an attempt by the parallel importers to defend against the enforcement of March 2006 settlement agreements on the basis that the settlement agreements were in restraint of trade and, therefore, void.

In  Mars Canada Inc. v Bemco Cash & Carry Inc. 2016 ONSC 7201 (CanLII), Justice F. L. Meyers of the Ontario Superior Court stated that:
[8] …. The law is unsettled as to whether a Canadian trade-mark holder can prevent third parties from selling products bearing the Canadian company’s trade-marks which are legitimate goods sourced from a foreign parent or affiliate of the Canadian trademark holder. …

The motions judge goes on to state:

[10] The parties argued at some length about the current state of the law concerning grey marketing in Canada and whether, in particular, a Canadian trade-mark holder is entitled to enforce its trade-marks to prevent sales in Canada by third parties of genuine product purchased from the trade-mark holder’s foreign parent company. I have not found it necessary to resolve that issue as part of the resolution of the motion before the court.

The Ontario Court of Appeal recently repeated this comment in an appeal of the foregoing decision in Mars Canada Inc. v. Bemco Cash & Carry Inc., 2018 ONCA 239:
[4]          …The law is unsettled as to whether a Canadian trademark holder can prevent this activity.

With respect, there is nothing that is “unsettled” about this question. Nor was anything unsettled even back in March 2006 (when the settlement agreements were entered into) about whether Canadian trademark law can be used to “thwart” parallel imports, which are by definition legitimate products put on the market by a trademark owner in another country. The answer was and is clearly “no” – except perhaps in very rare factual situations where the imported product may be of a materially different character or quality than the Canadian product and consumers get to buy a very different product from that which they expected. Usually, these grey market cases involve identical products – even from the very same ultimate source – that were acquired outside of the “official” or “authorized” channels of trade. While such parallel trade might displease the Canadian trademark owners or exclusive licensee or distributor who wishes to lessen competition and raise prices in the Canadian market, trademark law does not give them any such power.

The well-known 2007 Supreme Court of Canada decision in  Euro-Excellence Inc. v. Kraft Canada Inc., [2007] 3 SCR 20, involved the parallel importation of Toblerone and Côte d’Or chocolate bars concerning which Kraft sought unsuccessfully to “thwart” parallel importation by using copyright law instead of trademarks law. Kraft was the trademark owner in that case and if it could have used trademark law, it surely would have done so. It was represented by a very sophisticated IP litigation firm.


I made the prevailing arguments in that case in the SCC on behalf of the intervener Retail Council of Canada. Kraft tried to use copyright law because it knew that trademarks law wouldn’t work and was a non-starter. In fact, Kraft’s very experienced counsel told INTA, the major American based International Trademark Association, in a June 23, 2006 letter to encourage it to intervene in the SCC, that:
In light of the limitations imposed by legal authorities on enforcement of trade-mark rights in cases of parallel importation, Section 27(2) is very important to intellectual property right holders.

Indeed, as the trial Judge, whose decision was eventually overturned, noted that, even though it was not contested that Kraft owned the trademark, it did not try to invoke trademark law in its attempt to thwart the parallel importation of its chocolate bars. Instead, it developed an interesting strategy, alleging that the importation infringed its copyright in the artwork on the chocolate bars wrappers:
 [4] Kraft has developed an interesting strategy in an effort to thwart Euro Excellence's
distribution of these chocolate bars in Canada. To better appreciate the strategy, I should first say what it has not done. If it put distribution restrictions on Euro Excellence's supplier, it has not invoked them. Nor does it rely on trade-mark protection, although it alleges, and it is not contested, that it is the owner in Canada of the trade-marks "Côte d'Or" and "Toblerone". What it has done is take Canadian licensing rights in the artworks on the chocolate bar wrappers which have been copyrighted in Canada. It does not seek to enjoin Euro Excellence from distributing Toblerone and Côte d'Or chocolate bars. Rather, it seeks to enjoin it from distributing the copyrighted artwork on the wrappers. The idea is that the cost of re-wrapping or covering over the copyrighted artwork would act as a major disincentive...(emphasis added)
(highlight and emphasis added)


Even a trademark “owner” cannot use trademarks law to stop parallel importation. There are no developments since the Kraft case of which I am aware that would suggest otherwise.  I would be very interested in hearing from any expert counsel or academic who believes otherwise. Notwithstanding some obiter dicta in the Smith & Nephew, any attempt to change ownership of Canadian trademarks in favour of a Canadian subsidiary so as to enhance the chance of a more positive outcome in a grey marketing case is fraught with risks that include the potential loss of distinctiveness of the trademark and income tax issues.

The law was also clear before the Kraft decision.  See also:
·       Consumers Distributing Co. v. Seiko, [1984] 1 S.C.R. 583
·       Coca-Cola Ltd. et al. v. Pardhan et al. (1999) 85 C.P.R. (3d) 489 Affirming 77 C.P.R. (3d) 501 (FCA)
·       Smith & Nephew Inc. v. Glen Oak Inc. et al.; Beiersdorf Ag, Necessary Party (1996) 68 C.P.R. (3d) 153.

It is worth noting that this Bemco litigation – which has a very long and voluminous record – arises from a settlement agreement entered into in March, 2006 – at the very time when leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada was being sought in the Kraft case. Perhaps Bemco settled in 2006 based upon perceived uncertainty about whether copyright law could be used to “thwart” parallel importation of chocolate bars. I don’t know and can only speculate.

However, the law on trademarks and grey marketing/parallel imports seemed very clear at the time, as shown above, which is why Kraft had chosen to frame its litigation as a copyright case. I make no comment on the underlying issues concerning the Bemco settlement agreements or the ensuing litigation in which it was apparently been argued that the settlement agreements were in a “restraint of trade”.

Speaking generally, and not about this case in any way, there are potential issues regarding settlement agreements involving intellectual property that can raise serious antitrust and pubic interest issues. This has become quite obvious in “pay for delay” cases involving generic drugs, such as FTC v. Actavis that went to the US Supreme Court.

I reiterate that I make no comment on whether or not the 2006 agreements made commercial or legal sense at the time. However, they were apparently negotiated by sophisticated parties with experienced counsel. Courts are normally very reluctant to set aside such agreements, and that seems to be the conclusion reached here after much obviously expensive and complex litigation concerning which I make no comment, except for the following.

For whatever reasons, the Ontario Superior Court and now the Ontario Court of Appeal have recently stated that the law concerning trademarks and parallel imports is “unsettled”.  This is of some concern if other parties and counsel begin to believe that perfectly legal commercial activity involving grey marketing may now be illegal or even arguably so under Canadian trademarks law. The fact that the Ontario courts in this very protracted Bemco litigation seem to believe and feel the need to state that the law regarding trademarks and parallel imports is “unsettled” is in itself unsettling.

HPK


Thursday, October 17, 2013

Speech From the Throne 2013 – Will We Really Get Price Parity on Consumer Goods with the USA? IP Law is a Key Issue.

Yesterday’s  Speech from the Throne (#SFT13) contained two items that will require detailed consideration of amendments or clarifications of existing Canadian intellectual property law and amendments or clarifications to the anti-counterfeiting Bill C-56 from the previous session – or whatever it is numbered if and when it is resuscitated.

#SFT13 says:
·         “Our Government will ...Take further action to end geographic price discrimination against Canadians."
·         “And our Government will take additional action to protect Canadian consumers. Canadians are tired of hidden fees. They deserve to know the real cost of paying by debit or credit card. And they should not be charged more in Canada for identical goods that sell for less in the United States.”
Achieving these goals requires dealing with some extremely complex issues that have bedevilled courts and legislatures for decades. The elephant in the room is the issue of “parallel imports” or “grey market” goods – namely perfectly legitimate and authentic products that have been legally made and put on the market outside of Canada and which can be imported into Canada at a cheaper price than that demanded by the so-called “exclusive” distributor.  These good are by no means whatsoever “counterfeit” or “pirate” in any sense.

Despite the complexity of the “parallel imports” issue in terms of copyright law, some propositions are very simple.

Truly “free” trade cannot permit the imposition of “private tariffs” in the form of IP laws that permit geographic price discrimination or market segmentation. That would allow copyright law to become an unintended “instrument of trade control”, in the words of retired Justice Fish of the Supreme Court of Canada, and a very effective and unregulated “private tariff”.

Canada has explicit provisions in its Copyright Act regime that permit and encourage just such a regime for books. The situation for goods other than books is more complicated.

In 2007, the Supreme Court of Canada in the Kraft decision allowed a victory for the importer of “parallel import” or “grey market” Toblerone chocolate bars, largely based upon arguments that I made on behalf of the Retail Council of Canada. For a number of reasons, including the complexity of the decision and the issue itself, that victory has not been fully understood, even by some those importers who might benefit from it. Here’s an analysis I did for the Law Society of Upper Canada in 2008 that’s still useful.

Here is a summary of where the law now stands:
  1. The sui generis book regime in the Copyright Act works well to keep out commercial scale importation of parallel imports and my much missed “remainder” fine art books, but is ineffective to stop personal importation by travellers and by Canadians who cross-border shop from the comfort of their own home or with their smart phone via electronic commerce in very large quantities.
  2. Trade-marks law is ineffective to stop parallel imports.
  3. In theory, copyright on elements of packaging and labelling can be used to exclude parallel imports if the copyright is assigned to a Canadian entity that is different than the foreign entity that made the packaging.
  4. However, there’s a very good chance that such an assignment will trigger one or more of the following unintended and unfortunate consequences:
  • Undesirable corporate and tax law consequences
  • “Loss of distinctiveness” resulting in invalidity of trade-mark registrations
  • Defence and Counterclaim allegations in any vigorously fought litigation relating to sham transactions, copyright misuse, abuse, and/or various Competition Act issues. (I have raised such allegations in a test case proceeding which then fizzled and never went forward).

Thus, copyright law – other than in respect of books – is essentially a toothless tiger when it comes to excluding legitimate parallel imports. But a lot of supposedly well-informed importers don’t get that, for the reasons stated above and for other reasons, which I won’t go into here.

Therefore, clarification of the law would be useful and maybe even essential. Even experienced IP lawyers have been baffled by it for decades. It is little wonder, then, that many of their clients and even the general counsel of their clients often don’t understand it. Maybe Parliament needs to make it sufficiently clear in simple terms so that even a copyright lawyer can understand it. I look forward to helping to find the appropriate language.

In the case of books, unless we want to keep an arguably anachronistic, anomalous and clearly protectionist regime that guarantees higher prices to Canadian consumers and higher profits to Canadian “exclusive distributors” but little else in terms of benefits to Canada, it is essential that the Copyright Act be amended. Otherwise, we are certain to continue have higher book prices overall in Canada than the USA, unless the current market forces of Amazon and others put Canadian exclusive distributors and some publishers out of business, which would not be a desirable result. As for the rest of Canadian copyright law, clarifying language seems necessary for the reasons stated above.

The anti-counterfeiting Bill C-56 – which may or may not get revived in the new session – has countless confusing references that deal with parallel imports.  While the intention seems benign, the result may not be. Much more scrutiny and simplification may be required to ensure consistency with the Speech from the Throne statements.

In any event, these Speech from the Throne items cannot be achieved without considerable attention to IP details.

No doubt, the lawyers and lobbyists who would like to preserve the “private tariff” of IP to prevent real free trade and to geographically segment the Canadian market for price discrimination purposes are already hard at work to thwart the Government’s intention and to recover from their failed attempt in the Kraft case to hijack copyright law for this purpose.

And last but not least, let’s hope that the #CETA and #TPP agendas don’t derail the perfectly laudable sentiments in #SFT13.

In that connection, beware of the predictable efforts from the US Government and lobbyists representing American interests who will take their frequent posture of “do as we say, not as we do”. The US Supreme Court recently clarified in the Kirtsaeng decision that copyright law cannot be used to stop the parallel importation of goods – indeed the case was about books – largely based upon a “parade of horribles” that would result had it ruled otherwise.

As I occasionally explicitly reiterate, the views expressed on this blog are solely my own.

HPK

Sunday, October 28, 2012

Will Copyright Law Trump Free Trade and Domestic Resale Rights? Kirtsaeng v. Wiley - US Supreme Court May Decide


(Counsel in black robes preparing for Supreme Court oral argument - with apologies to the IPKat)

All eyes will be on the United States Supreme Court (“SCOTUS”) on Monday, October 29, 2012 when it will hear oral argument in the immensely important case of  Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. This involves parallel importation of text books into the United States that were legitimately manufactured abroad. The American copyrit owner, however, wanted to block them because they were being resold at lower prices than market would bear in the USA. If this fact situation sounds rather familiar to Canadians, it should. That was basically the issue in Euro-Excellence v. Kraft which was decided by the Supreme Court of Canada in 2007. That case involved chocolate bars and the frankly far-fetched argument that copyright in a small logo on the wrapping should suffice to prevent the parallel importation of these products. Our court split in interesting ways on that case, in which I made the prevailing argument on behalf of the Retail Council of Canada. Here’s a brief analysis that I did for the Law Society of Upper Canada the following year. Actually, tomorrow’s issue went to SCOTUS once before in 2010 in the Costco v. Omega case once before, but the Court split 4/4 on it. 

The American lawyers are busy sharpening the fine points of their submissions, which will, if things are normal, will likely be instantly deflected and perhaps shredded by the usually rather vigorous questions of the SCOTUS justices (other than one well known exception, who may perhaps break his seven year long record of silence during oral hearings, given his interest and evident insight into IP matters, which is shown in the very important 2005 eBay v. MercExchange decision which held that  injunctions do not automatically flow from a finding of infringement in patent cases).

The issue of the treatment of parallel imports under copyright law is one that the late, great Sir Hugh Laddie described as “one of the most difficult topics in copyright law.” It must always be remembered that “parallel importation” refers to the importation of completely legitimate goods through channels other than the one preferred by the local rights holder.

It should be noted that Canada has a special sui generis regime for books that allows for the blocking of parallel imports. This flows from well over a century of angst about cultural protectionism for Canadian publishers. While one can envisage such protectionism for cultural products such as books, where local industries may be imperiled, it is difficult to see why a similar doctrine should be used to control and prevent free trade in consumer or commercial goods. That said, there is also an argument that IP regimes that prevents international exhaustion and the application of the “first sale doctrine” permits the sale of products such as books and computer programs at lower prices in developing countries. The American statutory provisions are very different than those of Canada, and do not differentiate between books, chocolate bars or wrist watches.

This is a debate that will not end any time soon, and perhaps should be dealt with one day in a treaty – provided that there is any agreement at all on basic issues. One thing, however, is clear. To suggest that there can be truly “free trade” at the same time that copyright law can be used to prevent the parallel importation of chocolate bars, wrist watches and even text books is at best naïve and at worst, disingenuous and oxymoronic.

If SCOTUS reverses the decision below – which ruled in favour of blocking importation – there will likely be intense pressure on Congress to restore free trade for the USA. One of the most cogent arguments before the court is that any interpretation that blocks parallel importation of products made abroad is likely to encourage even more export of jobs and manufacturing overseas. Arguably, much more is at stake tomorrow even than the right of international "exhaustion". Many are arguing that, if SCOTUS upholds the Court below, everything from garage sales to library lending to private sale of used Toyotas could be affected and prevented by excessively aggressive copyright owners. 

Unlike Canada’s Supreme Court, there will not be a live video feed of Monday’s hearing. We will, however, see a transcript shortly after the hearing. A recording of the oral argument will be available in a few days.

There will be a very high powered post-mortem including counsel of record hosted by the very energetic and remarkable faculty at the Washington College of Law, at 3:30 PM on October 29, 2012, which I believe will be webcast live.
Note: This event has been cancelled due to Hurricane Sandy. Is this weather event an example of life imitating art with pathetic fallacy?


HPK


PS - Prof. Ariel Katz has an excellent blog about this case here.

PS - 

After a really fast read of the transcript, I think that the key moment may have been:

JUSTICE KENNEDY: But you have to look at those hypotheticals in order to decide this case.
MR. OLSON: Well, and that's --
JUSTICE KENNEDY: You're aware of the fact that if we write an opinion with the -- with the rule that you propose, that we should, as a matter of common sense, ask about the consequences of that rule. And that's what we are asking.
  
Seems at least six judges are really concerned about "the horribles" (i.e. re-selling used Toyotas and displaying Picassos,  lending library books etc.) and/or exporting jobs. EVen Ginsburg asked about exporting jobs.

There wasn't much discussion of any middle ground.

Olson's best answer to the "horribles" was that they haven't happened, that they are different cases and that there's always "fair use".

The latter point is frankly ridiculous in any situation that readily comes to mind no matter how much one might love fair use. And as to the former points, Supreme Courts exist to decide cases with broad implications as Olson obviously knows. I'm astonished that he tried to confine the implication of this case to these specific facts.

I detected some serious potential sympathy from at least Sotomayor, Kagan, Breyer, Kennedy, Rogers and Alito in the rough chronological order that I noted it.

One can never really read too much into Judges questions - but I'm going out on a limb to predict reversal.

And by at least 6-3.

And I've read some comments from pretty smart people on listserves and blogs who seem to think that the SCOTUS may indeed reverse....


 

Friday, January 16, 2009

Canada - EU FTA - Consultation Deadline January 20, 2009

A possible Canada - European Union (“EU”) Free Trade Agreement (“FTA”) is in the works. For whatever reason, the Government is calling it a “comprehensive economic agreement” and not an FTA. On December 20, 2008 the Canadian Government announced a consultation process.

There is an effectively hidden deadline to comment of next Tuesday, January 20, 2009.

There is a lengthy paper setting the stage for the many issues that could arise in these negotiations. There is a ten page discussion of IP issues.

The IP discussion does not explain the potential complexities and controversies that could arise. The Government of Canada expects a response from the pubic by January 20, 2009. This is somewhat astonishing, given the announcement of “consultation” only on December 20, 2009 - five days before Christmas. It is unclear why this extremely short deadline is in effect.

There is probably little awareness of the deadline. True, the notice was published in the Canada Gazette. But, as the late Gordon F. Henderson said, the best way to keep a secret in Ottawa can be to publish it in the Canada Gazette.

Considering the timing of the announcement just before the Christmas break, the focusing of attention on the forthcoming budget, and the coincidence of the one month deadline with the US Obama Inauguration events, the short deadline suggests that the Government wants this initiative to get as little attention as possible.

From an IP standpoint, there are some obvious opportunities and pitfalls depending on point of view:

1. The EU is has a life plus 70 year copyright term and is heading towards a 95 year term for sound recordings. The EU will clearly not harmonize downwards to meet Canada on this. Canada will be under great pressure to harmonize “upwards” to these lengthy terms. This would clearly be highly controversial in Canada.

2. The EU will doubtless press for quick Canadian ratification of the 1996 WIPO internet treaties, even though the EU has not ratified these treaties to date and has been claiming that such ratification is imminent for many years.

3. The EU is very aggressive on “appellations d’origine” or geographical indications. Does Canada want to take away the right of its cheese manufacturers, retailers and restaurants to sell domestic “parmesan” cheese, for example?

4. The EU has a very complex labyrinth of laws concerning parallel imports or “grey market” products. Essentially, they amount to a strong “Fortress Europe” regime to keep parallel imports out but such products are allowed to flow freely within the EU if they have been imported with the appropriate “consent”, whatever that may mean. If goods can flow freely between Canada and the EU, the EU will probably want Canada to drastically change its laws to tighten up the possibility of parallel imports into Canada because Canada could become a “back door” to Europe. This could prove costly for Canadian consumers, because IP has hitherto been essentially ineffective to block parallel imports of consumer goods into Canada, except for books. The EU is generally a very “high price” market for the types of goods that are subject to parallel trade, perhaps is large part because of its IP policies on parallel imports.

5. The EU has much more a much active antitrust policy and enforcement mind set and mechanism than Canada, and is extremely cognizant that IP rights are prone to abuse and other anticompetitive practices.

6. The EU will no doubt press for expanded ex officio border actions without Court orders that could interfere with legitimate trade and may not be necessary or desirable from a Canadian standpoint. This effort will no doubt be linked to ACTA.

7. The EU also has an unfortunate database protection regime, which has led to some bad results in terms of “extraction” of information. Whether the EU will press for this remains to be seen.

HK

Friday, January 09, 2009

Kraft v. Euro -Excellence #2 Settled

The sequel involving the same parties to the 2007 Kraft v. Euro-Excellence case decided in the Supreme Court of Canada has been settled, according to a press release from Kraft, which describes this as an “important copyright case.” The press release says that “The Judgment is important as it supports the rights of owners of copyright in Canada to stop distributors from selling products without the consent of the owner of copyright in the product packaging.”

This, of course, is not correct. A consent judgment, which this was, reflects a settlement between the particular parties involved, which is usually made on a business decision basis. Such a judgment clearly affects those parties but does not have a legally binding precedential effect on the rest of the world. This particular litigation never really got off the ground and was at a very preliminary stage.

Kraft’s current theory following the 2007 Supreme Court decision is that calling a piece of paper an “assignment” rather than an “exclusive license” will enable the blocking of the parallel importation of chocolate bars and other non-copyrightable products based upon copyright in some element of the packaging or labelling. However, this strategy has not resulted in any reasoned decision blocking parallel imports to date in Canada.

In fact, any party now being sued for copyright infringement in respect of the parallel importation of legitimate goods based upon an “assignment” strategy involving an element of packaging or labelling should know that there are arguable defences available based upon such doctrines as copyright misuse, as explicitly mentioned and left open by the Supreme Court in its 2007 decision.

It is also quite possible, where appropriate, to convert any summary “application” brought by a plaintiff in these circumstances into a full-fledged “action” in order to ensure that all viable defences and counterclaims can be asserted.

My detailed comment on the 2007 Supreme Court decision can be found here. As I said in the conclusion of that comment:
Moreover, if lower courts are somehow persuaded to come to a different overall result than the one reached by the SCC, one can certainly expect pressure for an immediate amendment to restore the status quo ante of free trade and competition in the Canadian marketplace, unimpeded by assertions of copyright in mere elements of packaging material.
HK

Thursday, May 01, 2008

ACTA Analysis

CIPPIC provides some much needed and, indeed, exemplary analysis of the mysterious ACTA (anti-counterfeiting) initiative being led by the USA.

We all deplore counterfeiting. But how many dolphins will be caught in America's anti-counterfeiting net?

HK

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Vaver Live today on Euro Excellence v. Kraft

Tune in for a webcast at 1:00 PM today, Wednesday October 24, 2007 for Prof. David Vaver, formerly from Osgoode Hall Law School and now at Oxford, who will lecture on the SCC’s Kraft’s decision:

Osgoode advises that:
Professor Vaver’s lecture will assess how the Supreme Court is interpreting Canada’s intellectual property laws and how its decisions may affect legislative policy. Among the cases considered will be the Euro-Excellence v. Kraft Canada (2007), where an attempt to use the copyright law to block parallel imports of chocolate bars into Canada was narrowly repelled. The decision, involving four widely divergent opinions, recalls Milton’s lines from Paradise Lost: “Chaos Umpire sits, And by decision more imbroiles the fray By which he Reigns: next him high Arbiter Chance governs all.”
Dr Giuseppina D'Agostino advises that:
By popular demand Osgoode's James Lewtas lecture featuring University of Oxford Professor David Vaver will be webcast live starting at 1:00PM Eastern Time on Oct 24 in Windows Media format.

I am advised that the link to the webcast should be available on the Osgoode Hall Law School homepage and that the event should also be archived online on the Osgoode Conferences and Seminars page.

I must confess that I have a particular interest here. On behalf of my client, the Retail Council of Canada, I presented the arguments at the Supreme Court of Canada that prevailed in this case. Here’s my early summary of the outcome.

With David's well deserved reputation as a renowned scholar, author and teacher of copyright law, his take on this will doubtless be both very interesting and very important.

I truly have no idea of what he will say, but I’m really looking forward to hearing it. And I'm so pleased that I and doubtless others persuaded Osgoode (my alma mater) to do this "live." Thanks, Pina!

HK

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

"ACTA" - a New Plurilateral Policy Platform

A potentially important announcement from Washington, Brussels (EU), and Ottawa (and doubtless elsewhere) today re a proposed Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement - “ACTA.”

According to US Ambassador Schwab:
The ACTA would complement the Administration’s work to encourage other countries to meet the enforcement standards of the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) under the World Trade Organization, and to comply with other international IPR agreements. It will not involve any changes to the TRIPS Agreement. Rather, the goal is to set a new, higher benchmark for enforcement that countries can join on a voluntary basis. The negotiations represent a cooperative effort by the governments involved, and will not be conducted as part of any international organization.

The list of currently interested countries read a bit like preaching to the choir:
[US] Trading partners engaged in discussions so far include Canada, the European Union (with its 27 Member States), Japan, Korea, Mexico, New Zealand, and Switzerland.
Most of these countries have adequate and effective levels of substantive law and enforcement mechanisms.

So - these questions arise:

• What’s this really about?
• Will the US “insist” on ratcheting up substantive law - for example by defining downloading, “making available” and DRM/TPM circumvention as “piracy”?
• Will the US and EU insist that all countries have a common copyright term - for the sake of better and more symmetrical “enforcement”?
• Will legitimate parallel imports get caught, like dolphins in a drift net?
• Where are WIPO and WTO in this?
• Is this an exercise in plurilateral policy laundering?

There is clearly potential for positive developments here. Indeed, counterfeiting involving trade-marks is morally, economically and even criminally wrong - especially in the thankfully rare cases when health and safety are involved. Commercial scale copyright piracy is also quite wrong - although certain elements in the record industry apply the word “piracy” rather promiscuously to include all manner of private copying that they cannot control - thereby labelling hundreds of millions of ordinary internet users as “pirates.”

But some rights owner lobbyists and sympathetic officials have a tendency to conflate “effective action” on enforcement issues with substantive law augmentation. We saw an example of this in the Grokster case in the US Supreme Court, and I was asked to write an “amicus” brief on it.

What we don’t want to see are excessive barriers to the flow of legitimate goods, including parallel imports - which are legitimate by definition. There is a danger that customs officers and even lawyers won’t be sure of the difference in some cases. If that happens, millions of dollars of legitimate goods may get tied up or cost more to clear at a border. And we don’t want to see a backdoor mechanism to increase substantive laws in ways that threaten Canadian cultural and economic sovereignty.

And we don’t want to see a good cause become the pretext for bad laws. Think 9/11. The Bush administration has tried to brand many critics of its excessive post 9/11 incursions on civil liberties as soft on terrorism. And we have seen the results ranging from common inconvenience at the boarder to tragedy. Will critics of potentially excessive ACTA measures be labelled as proponents of counterfeiting and piracy, and enemies of artists and creators?

There are also the dangers of a plurilateral policy platform dominated by the US and to a lesser extent the EU - especially since the often too low but at least established minimal institutional transparency of WTO and WIPO won’t be there. We may get a fait accompli that Parliament will be asked - or told - to implement. Or some would say “rubber stamp.” That’s how policy laundering happens - things that couldn’t get of the ground domestically are agreed upon far away by a few senior bureaucrats and politicians - and are brought home effectively as domestic law. All democratic countries should be worried about this.

BTW, here's a rather balanced British view from one of my favourite felines, the IPKat.

And here's a take from IP-Watch on the formidable forces pushing this initiative including Mary Bono - who famously told Congress that:
Actually, Sonny wanted the term of copyright protection to last forever. I am informed by staff that such a change would violate the Constitution. … As you know, there is also [Motion Picture Association of America president] Jack Valenti's proposal for term to last forever less one day. Perhaps the Committee may look at that next Congress.
This may provide a clue as to where these talks may be headed...

Update: Here's Minister David Emerson jumping on the bandwagon.

HK